Wild Planet Albacore Solid Wild Tuna In Extra Virgin Olive Oil had the 3 Gs: "good texture, good flavor, and would be really good in a tuna salad," wrote Ali, our associate groceries editor.

I thought Costco-brand tuna would be a big winner, especially as quite a few friends had hyped it up. But it was quite dry, and the fact that I had to buy eight cans for $17.99 was a big ...